| Filson Young: Silvester
Mazzarella's introduction to his forthcoming biography
I liked books about prostitutes, there were a good many then,
and vividly recollect a novel called The Sands of Pleasure written
by a man called Filson Young. It must have been well written otherwise
I would never have remembered it so perfectly to this day. It was
about an Englishman's love affair with an expensive demi-mondaine
in Paris.
Jean Rhys
When she was a young girl in the West Indies Jean Rhys came across
Filson's book in the local library. Writing her autobiography in
old age she remembered it. Perhaps The Sands of Pleasure began the
process that in the twenties and thirties took her too to Paris,
where the Bohemian life she lived inspired memorable novels of her
own.
Today nobody reads The Sands of Pleasure - and hardly anybody under
the age of seventy has heard of Filson Young. In my family he was
the legendary wicked uncle. We once set eyes on one another but
as he died when I was one I don't remember the occasion. My mother's
father Tom Young was Filson's elder brother, but though I lived
in Tom's home until his death when I was nine, I don't remember
him telling me anything about Filson. It was through the women of
the family, half-repelled and half-fascinated by him, that the anecdotes
came. My grandmother (Tom's widow) disapproved of Filson's irregular
sex-life. No one could be quite sure whether he had been married
once or twice, and as for other women - well, better pretend they
never existed. Besides, she could never forgive his description
of her bustling self: 'When you go for a walk with Agnes you have
to run round the corners.' Stories abounded of his resourcefulness
and arrogance. One day he was doing some research in the royal library
at Windsor when King Edward VII came into the room. 'Who are you?'
said the king. 'Filson Young,' came the answer, 'Who are you?' Or
there was the time he was eating at a restaurant when the table
manners of a man nearby began to irritate him. 'Waiter!' he is supposed
to have called: 'put a screen round that table' He could always
bluff his way past ticket-collectors and commissionaires to get
into places where he had no business to be, and he was the sort
of snob who would tick you off for saying 'maids' when you should
have said 'servants'.
There was a shelf of books he had written in the glass-fronted
bureau-bookcase that stood in my grandparents' drawing room and
followed me from home to home down the years, but it was not until
the early seventies that it occurred to me to read them. I was surprised
by their variety and vitality. Fiction, war reportage, music criticism,
book reviews, a complete guide to motoring from as early as 1904,
an account of learning to fly in late middle age, a book on the
Titanic published in the year the ship sank, and another on broadcasting
from 1933, and - reprinted from newspapers and periodicals - volumes
of personal essays or what today we would call newspaper 'columns'
that threw light on his activities and personality. All this was
expressed in a kind of purple 'fine writing' not likely to appeal
to the less pretentious and more egalitarian age I had grown up
in, yet the sheer energy of it all commanded respect. I determined
to find out all I could about him. I spoke to the dwindling band
of relations and friends who remembered him and tracked down people
who had had professional dealings with him and advertised in the
press for information. Those few to whom his name meant anything
at all often remembered him in a fragmentary way: 'Oh yes he was
the man who tried to get the BBC to broadcast the odds on horse-races,
wasn't he?' or 'I shall never forget his book on the Titanic. A
minor masterpiece'.
I spent weeks in the British Library's newspaper department at
Colindale searching the crumbling pages in huge tomes of bound copies
of the newspapers he had written for and studied old radio scripts
and staff memos filed away in the BBC's written archives at Caversham.
I had the eerie experience of hearing him speak to me in scraps
of early radio broadcasts preserved on disc at Broadcasting House,
and was just in time to save a long pink envelope full of newspaper
cuttings and marked 'Young, Filson, Naval Expert, DEAD' which was
about to be thrown out of the private files of the Daily Express.
From an ancient handwritten ledger of payments to freelance writers
I discovered exactly what he had written for the Manchester Guardian
when all contributions were printed anonymously. From a university
library in the USA came, on a single reel of microfilm made specially
for me, over 750 letters that had passed between Filson and his
publisher and friend Grant Richards, throwing light on the origins
and fortunes of many of his books and giving clues as to the how
and where and when of his reputed love affair with Richards' independent-minded
wife.
Considering how completely his work has been forgotten, I was amazed
to find again and again how highly he had been thought of in his
own time. Before he was twenty-one he had not only published his
first book but also an organ fugue which was accepted by the most
famous music publishers of the day. When he wrote about music, a
leading critic described his work as 'by far superior to anything
yet produced by the English writers on music'. When he wrote a piece
about going backstage at the pantomime and sent it to the Manchester
Guardian not only its famous editor, C.P.Scott, but its owner too
wanted him to become a regular contributor. When Scott sent him
to South Africa to cover the march to relieve Mafeking he managed
to be the first Journalist into the beleaguered town, and when his
dispatches to the Guardian from South Africa were published as a
book, Kipling was impressed enough to urge him to write stories.
Instead he left Manchester at the age of 24 and plunged into London
journalism, simultaneously producing not only a book on Ireland
said by one reviewer to contain descriptive writing comparable to
the 'purple patches of the great masters of English prose', but
also the book that hadn't existed when he had bought his first car,
a comprehensive guide to cars and motoring that, suitably updated,
was to be reprinted eight times.
Grant Richards now decided that Filson should give up London and
journalism and go to live in a village in western Cornwall and write
a novel; this coincided with the break-up of Filson's first marriage
(to an officer's daughter he had met in South Africa), and Richards
gave him paid work as a reader of manuscripts submitted to his firm
for publication. The result of this arrangement was The Sands of
Pleasure, which not only thrilled the young Jean Rhys in Dominica
but shocked a puritanical Edinburgh bookseller so much that he burned
it in public. The critics bracketed Filson together with E.M. Forster
as one of the most promising young novelists in England, while The
Sands of Pleasure made much needed money for both author and
publisher.
After he was thirty success did not come to him so easily. The
books that followed The Sands of Pleasure did less well and he went
back to journalism, becoming in the years before the First World
War an establishment essayist admired by Henry James, caricatured
by Max Beerbohm and 'blasted' by Wyndham Lewis. In 1912 the essayist
and novelist in him came together in what is in effect a documentary
novel on the Titanic Richards made sure it reached the bookshops
only 37 days after the ship sank, but it shows no signs of hasty
writing and has been considered by some Filson's best book. Two
years later James Joyce, as yet unknown, was disappointed when Richards
failed to persuade Filson to write an introduction for the first
edition of Joyce's collection of stories, Dubliners, which Filson
had been one of the first to praise when the manuscript had reached
him in his capacity as Richards' reader eight years before.
With the coming of war Filson by devious means attached himself
to the staff of Admiral Beatty, then commanding the Navy's most
exciting unit, the crack battle cruiser squadron in the North Sea.
Early in 1915 he saw action with the battle cruisers at the Battle
of the Dogger Bank and was lucky to survive. Soon after, a quarrel
with Beatty lost him his place on the Admiral's staff, though they
remained friends. He finished the war as special correspondent first
for the Daily Mail and then for the Times in Spain and Portugal,
where he ran up vast expense accounts entertaining VIPs and doubled
as an Admiralty Intelligence agent whose job was to keep an eye
on the movements of German agents and U-boats in and around the
officially neutral Spanish ports. He started the twenties confidently
with a new marriage (his second, and this one produced two sons),
and writing up his naval experiences. It was another of his better
books, With the Battle Cruisers (published in America as With Beatty
in the North Sea). This combined an attack on Admiralty policy and
methods with an eyewitness description of the Dogger Bank action
as seen from a precarious perch in the crow's nest of Beatty's battered
flagship Lion. The book was serialized in the Times, discussed in
Parliament and praised by Winston Churchill, Conan Doyle and the
Foreign Secretary (Lord Curzon).
All this publicity led to nothing much. By 1921 people were tired
of hearing about the war and in any case did not like being told
that those who ran the glorious Royal Navy might have been less
than perfect. Returning to journalism again, Filson became editor
of the weekly Saturday Review, a twenties equivalent of the modern
Spectator, to which he had contributed regularly as a columnist
for many years before the war. He greatly extended its arts coverage,
among much else starting James Agate on his famous career as a West
End drama critic and encouraging him to write what Agate later claimed
as the first piece of serious film criticism to appear in the British
press, its subject Charlie Chaplin's The Kid. Among Filson's other
more memorably acts as editor was to accuse Conan Doyle of cheating
at a spiritualist seance they had both attended. Doyle retorted:
'The only credulity shown by any of the company was our believing
that you were a gentleman. This also you may publish.'
Sacked after two and a half years by a proprietor who resented
being told by his editor that a proprietor's only function was to
sign cheques, Filson approached Sir John (later Lord) Reith with
a mass of ideas for the development of the infant BBC. Many of these
were good ideas and for the last fourteen years of his life he was
on the payroll as a programmes adviser and produced many programmes
of his own, notably a series of religious folk plays from western
Cornwall, a breakthrough--in regional broadcasting that was well
ahead of its time. The Reith Lectures of today have developed from
the BBC's National Lectures of the thirties which owed their existence
to an idea of Filson's and to his conviction, often forcibly expressed
in the Radio Times column he wrote every week from 1930 to 1936,
that broadcasting should educate as well as entertain, a view shared
by Reith. By the thirties his cultural elitism and mandarin prose
were increasingly out of step with the times.
Nonetheless, despite failing health (not improved by an addiction
to whisky) he threw himself with all his old vigour into new experiences.
At 58 he learned to fly, giving a running commentary in a series
of radio talks as he did so. In 1933 he annoyed Reith by prophesying
in the Radio Times that the time would come when big sporting events
like the Grand National and FA Cup Final would be televised; four
years after this he was chosen to be the BBC's first television
programmes adviser. Full of ideas, he could hardly wait to start,
but heart failure killed him before he could do anything. He died
bitter and disappointed. As early as 1909 he had written that it
was his 'desolate habit not to be able to write otherwise than for
publication'. He became convinced that he had never developed talents
as a serious artist that were within him, and no amount of learning
to fly and planning television programmes could make up for that.
Yet he had impressed people; when James Agate heard of his death
he wrote in his diary: 'A man easy to misjudge: a man with something
of the eagle about him'. Were those who praised his work in his
lifetime wrong? Or did he produce masterpieces which we have unjustly
forgotten? Neither, I suspect. Our lives are so short and crowded
that a great deal that is interesting and worthwhile from the past
must necessarily be put aside and forgotten, especially if it does
not seem to connect with the fads and fashions of the moment'. Peter
Green, discussing Filson"s contemporary A.A. Milne, once wrote:
'It will often happen that a minor talent, moving with the flow
of contemporary opinion rather than against it, can, for that very
reason, illuminate a period better than the independent creative
spirit.' I'm sure Filson thought of himself as an independent creative
spirit rather than a minor talent, but I think he would have seen
the point. As with countless others whom time has passed by, it
may do us good to recall him from oblivion if we can and get to
know him. And it may be quite fun too.
|